Job Losses Higher Among People Of Color During Coronavirus Pandemic

Apr 22, 2020
Originally published on April 25, 2020 6:04 am

Until a few weeks ago, Melissa St. Hilaire worked the night shift taking care of a 95-year-old woman for a family in Miami.

"I help her to go to the bathroom, use the bathroom, and I watch TV with her, and I comb her hair sometimes in the night," she said.

But one day in March, the woman's daughter told her not to come back, saying she wanted to protect her mother during the coronavirus pandemic.

St. Hilaire is black and a Haitian immigrant. And her situation is an example of what early data from this crisis shows: People of color have lost work at greater rates than white workers.

The March jobs data show a number of racial and ethnic disparities in the economic impact of the coronavirus. For example: the share of white people who are employed fell by 1.1% last month. That rate fell by substantially more for black people (a 1.6% drop), Asian Americans (1.7%), and Latinos (2.1%). Economist Christian Weller highlighted this data and more at Forbes earlier this month.

In addition, a survey from the left-leaning Data for Progress found that 45% of black workers have lost jobs or had their hours cut, compared with 31% for white workers. (Samples were not large enough to break out other racial and ethnic groups.)

Losing her job landed St. Hilaire in dire straits. She was able to delay her rent payment after she talked to her landlord.

Melissa St. Hilaire was an in-home aide to a 95-year-old woman before the coronavirus hit. Now she is out of work.
Courtesy of Melissa St. Hilaire

"​I said to her my situation. She said, 'OK.' She understood my situation. She gave me more days," St. Hilaire said, but she added that shelter isn't her only concern. "Two weeks before [that], I was out of food. That's crazy."

She ended up getting some food supplies from a local aid group. She plans to apply for unemployment and also has a GoFundMe whose proceeds she plans to share with fellow domestic aides.

A big reason for these racial and ethnic gaps has to do with the workplaces that have been hurt most by the economic crisis.

"We know which industries are being hit the hardest," says Gbenga Ajilore, senior economist at the left-leaning Center for American Progress. "So we look at leisure and hospitality, transportation, utilities, industries that are first ones were hit really hard. We also know service — think hairdressers, salons. We know which ones are getting hit hard, and we know who's in those occupations."

People of color — and in the case of domestic workers like St. Hilaire, women of color — are disproportionately in those occupations. Nearly three-quarters of domestic workers were out of work the week of April 6, according to a survey from the National Domestic Workers Alliance.

Similar patterns turn up in other industries hurt most by the coronavirus slowdown. The latest jobs report showed more than 450,000 job losses in leisure and hospitality — a category that includes hotels and restaurants. Black, Asian and Latino workers are all disproportionately represented in the hotel industry, and Latino workers have heavy representation in restaurants.

That includes Erick Velasquez, who is Mexican American and who until recently was head bartender at a Greek restaurant in Houston.

"Everything just happened so quick. We're watching the news, and they talk about COVID-19, and nobody really thought much about it," he said. "And then a few days after then that's when they — the city or the county — closed down dining rooms for restaurants everywhere."

Velasquez has managed to find a temporary job — helping his fellow laid-off workers. He's a case worker now at the Southern Smoke Foundation, a nonprofit that supports people in the restaurant industry. And he sees racial and ethnic gaps among the people he's helping.

"​Everybody in the restaurant industry is hurting, but more so, it's the people that you don't really see when you go into a restaurant," Velasquez said. "It's like the back of the house workers, the immigrant community, the people of color."

There's also evidence of disparities in who is able to work from home during this crisis: 30% of white people and 37% of Asian Americans could work from home in 2017 and 2018, according to the Labor Department. Meanwhile, only 20% of black people could. In addition, only 16% of Latinos could work from home, compared to nearly twice as many non-Latinos.

The March jobs report that much of this analysis is based on only captured the start of the economic crisis created by COVID-19. The April report, which will be released May 8, will show if racial gaps have persisted.

If those gaps do continue, it could make existing inequalities worse. The unemployment rates for blacks and Latinos, for example, are always higher than the broader national unemployment rate. Wages for blacks and Latinos are also lower than for other groups.

Ajilore thinks it was easier to ignore these types of gaps when the economy was humming along with record-low unemployment. Now, the economic crisis brought about by the pandemic is holding a magnifying glass to those gaps.

​"Once this pandemic hit, then it's like you see the cracks in the structure," he said.

And the more coronavirus widens those cracks, the harder they will be to fill.

Copyright 2020 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

SCOTT SIMON, HOST:

Earlier this year, the jobless rates for black and Latino Americans were near record lows. Coronavirus has changed that as the first round of layoffs fell hardest on minority workers. NPR's Danielle Kurtzleben reports on why many are so vulnerable on the economic side of this crisis.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED NPR BROADCAST)

DANIELLE KURTZLEBEN, BYLINE: Until a few weeks ago, Melissa St. Hilaire worked for a family in Miami on the night shift, taking care of a 95-year-old woman.

MELISSA ST HILAIRE: I help her to go to the bathroom, use the bathroom. And I watch TV with her, and I comb her hair out, sometimes, in the night.

KURTZLEBEN: But one day in March, the woman's daughter told her not to come back, saying she wanted to protect her mother during the coronavirus pandemic. That put St. Hilaire in dire straits. She was able to delay her rent payment. She describes the conversation with her landlord.

ST HILAIRE: I said to her my situation. She said OK. She understood my situation. She gave me more days. Two weeks before, I was out of food. That's crazy.

KURTZLEBEN: St. Hilaire and her 6-year-old son had nothing to eat, so they got help from a local aid group. St. Hilaire is black and a Haitian immigrant. And she's part of what the first data from this crisis have shown - that people of color have lost work at greater rates than white workers. A big part of that is because of which industries the job losses are happening in. According to Benga Ajilore, senior economist at the left-leaning Center for American Progress. He spoke to NPR via Skype.

OLUGBENGA AJILORE: We know which industries are being hit the hardest, so we look at leisure and hospitality, transportation, utilities industries that are first ones that were hit really hard. We also know service - so you can think hairdressers, salons. We know which ones are getting hit hard, and we know who is in those occupations.

KURTZLEBEN: It's disproportionately workers of color. And in the case of domestic workers like St. Hilaire, it's women of color. Nearly three-quarters of domestic workers were out of work in recent weeks, according to a survey from the National Domestic Workers Alliance. Similar patterns show up in industries hit hardest by the coronavirus slowdown. Black, Asian and Latino workers, for example, are all disproportionately represented in the hotel industry, and Latino workers like Erick Velasquez have heavy representation in restaurants.

ERICK VELASQUEZ: I've been working in the restaurant industry since I was 16, as soon as I was able to apply for a job. And I grew up with a single mother taking care of her two kids and her mom. So ever since I was young, I knew I had to, like, kind of help out.

KURTZLEBEN: After college, he went back to restaurant work, eventually becoming head bartender at a Greek restaurant in Houston. But once coronavirus spread, the restaurant bar didn't really need tending anymore. Velasquez has managed to find a temporary job - helping his fellow laid-off workers. He's a case worker now at the Southern Smoke Foundation, a nonprofit that supports people in the restaurant industry. And he sees racial and ethnic gaps among the people he's helping.

VELASQUEZ: Everybody in the restaurant industry is hurting right now. But more so, it's the people that you don't really see when you go into a restaurant. It's the back of the house - the workers, you know, the immigrant community, the people of color.

KURTZLEBEN: There's also evidence that black and Latino workers are less able to work from home than white and Asian workers. If all this persists, it could make existing inequalities worse. The unemployment rates for blacks and Latinos are always higher than the broader national unemployment rate. Wages for blacks and Latinos are also lower than for other groups. Ajilore thinks it was easier to ignore these types of gaps when the economy was humming along with record-low unemployment. Now the economic crisis brought about by the pandemic is holding a magnifying glass to those gaps.

AJILORE: Once this pandemic hit, then it's like you see the cracks in the structure.

KURTZLEBEN: And the more coronavirus widens those cracks, the harder they will be to fill. Danielle Kurtzleben, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.