How To Keep Money From Messing Up Your Marriage

Mar 8, 2016
Originally published on March 12, 2016 9:06 pm

Mary Fusillo and her husband, Bob, have been married for 20 years. She met him on a blind date in Houston. Right away, she knew she liked him.

He was very intellectual, and he "read jazz biographies of dead jazz musicians," she says, laughing.

"And I was used to guys that went hunting on the weekends," she adds.

They fell in love and got married. Pretty soon they had a house and kids — twins, actually.

But within a few years, there was trouble.

"He was a good husband," Fusillo, now in her mid-50s, says with absolute conviction. "He's always done all the cooking, which is great."

He gave the kids baths and did household chores. So what was the trouble?

"The money thing always made us crazy," Fusillo says.

JOIN NPR'S 'YOUR MONEY AND YOUR LIFE' FACEBOOK GROUP

At the time, Fusillo says, she was working fewer hours to juggle her job with taking care of the kids. She was a nurse; he was a chemical engineer.

Her husband was making more money than she was, but they were splitting their expenses down the middle.

So after her share of the child care, groceries and bills, Fusillo says, she was feeling pretty broke much of the time.

"It would be a week before payday and I would have like 20 bucks," she says. "And I would go to my dad and say, 'Can I have a hundred dollars?' and my dad would be like, 'Well, what's up?' " she re-enacts his one-eyebrow-raised question. "I'd say, 'Please just give me a hundred bucks,' " she says. "It was bad."

Oftentimes one spouse doesn't realize how big an issue money is becoming for the other person. Fusillo says that's what was going on with her husband.

They weren't having money arguments per se. But over time, Fusillo got increasingly frustrated about it — to the point where she says she's surprised they didn't get divorced, "because I had such overwhelming resentment."

Why It's So Hard To Talk About Money

Disagreements about money are one of the most difficult conflicts for people in relationships to resolve. There's little instruction in how to manage our finances with a spouse or partner. And if you do it wrong, it can mess everything up.

"We know that these discussions or conflicts concerning money are difficult for couples to handle," says Lauren Papp, a psychologist and professor at the University of Wisconsin, Madison.

Papp conducted a study of 100 married couples who kept diary entries about their arguments. During the 15-day period of the study, the spouses reported squabbling more often about issues other than money — for example, the kids or household chores.

But Papp found that money can be one of the most difficult and damaging areas of conflict. Part of the problem is that it's very difficult for couples to talk about money issues and resolve them, "and partners walk away from these discussions learning this is an issue we can't handle, I feel very frustrated, I feel very devalued by my partner," Papp says.

That's because so much is wrapped up in money, she says — who's making more of it, who's sacrificed their work life more to take care of the kids, "feelings about our self-worth, how much we're contributing, how much we've accomplished."

So What's A Couple To Do?

Kitty Bressington is a financial adviser in Rochester, N.Y., who specializes in helping couples. First, she says, you need to "get all of the issues out on the table, work through a budget." That means coming to some agreement on "yours, mine, ours." Couples often need to set spending limits.

"Those all come from being able to talk about money, which as a society we're not very good at," Bressington says.

Keeping all your money separate is probably the wrong approach, Bressington says, but she also doesn't think it's a good idea for a couple to just throw all their money together in one account and hope for the best.

The exact structure depends on the particular couple. But she recommends the following as a good way to organize your finances:

  • Set up a joint account to cover the basic bills.
  • Set up a plan with automatic contributions to a retirement account, college savings account and other long-term savings goals.
  • Then, each partner in the couple should get a set amount of spending or "fun" money every month that's discretionary.

"If you decide [the fun money is], say, $250 a month, and that fits within your budget, and one person wants to blow his $250 and the other person wants to save her $250, then that's OK because you've set those ground rules," Bressington says.

She advises many couples to take out that spending money in cash — no credit cards.

"We're tactile," she says. "Sometimes I need to put people back in touch with a dollar bill."

Also, many experts say if you go to a financial adviser, pick one who works for a simple "fee only" (an actual, legally binding designation) — unlike many who make commissions steering you into pricey mutual funds.

As for Mary Fusillo, she and her husband eventually did figure out a better system. Now she's pretty much in charge of managing their finances. It's something he didn't like to do anyway, she says. And that, she says, changed their relationship completely.

"He still makes more money than I do," she says, "but we're a team about it."

And that's a very good place to be.

JOIN NPR'S 'YOUR MONEY AND YOUR LIFE' FACEBOOK GROUP, an online community featuring stories from some of the best investors and financial experts on the planet along with crowdsourced wisdom curated and overseen by NPR reporters and editors.

Copyright 2018 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

RENEE MONTAGNE, HOST:

Let's give some thought now to money and marriage. It might be nice if one had nothing to do with the other, but in sickness and in health, through good times and bad, money is one of the things most likely to cause discord in a long-term relationship. Whether you're just starting out or you've been together for years, NPR's Chris Arnold has some tips on the best way to achieve marital monetary bliss.

CHRIS ARNOLD, BYLINE: Mary Fusillo met her husband Bob on a blind date in Houston, Texas, and she knew right away that she liked him.

MARY FUSILLO: This was somebody who was very intellectual - like, read jazz biographies of dead jazz musicians (laughter). And I was used to guys that went hunting on the weekends. And he was a chemical engineer.

ARNOLD: Nothing against hunting, mind you. But anyway, they fell in love, got married, a house, kids - twins actually. But within a few years, there was trouble.

FUSILLO: It's not - he was a good husband. He's always done all the cooking, which is great. He gave the kids a bath. The money thing always made us crazy.

ARNOLD: Fusillo says she was working fewer hours to juggle taking care of the kids, and she was a nurse. Her husband was making more money than she was, but they were splitting their expenses down the middle. And so after paying her share of the child care and some bills, Fusillo says she was pretty much always broke.

FUSILLO: It would be a week before payday and I would have, like, 20 bucks. And I would go to my dad and say can I have $100? And my dad would be like, well, what's up? And I'd say please, just give me a hundred bucks. It was bad.

ARNOLD: Oftentimes, the spouse in a relationship doesn't even realize how big an issue this is becoming for the other person. Fusillo says that's what was going on with her husband. But over time, Fusillo got increasingly frustrated about it to the point, actually, she says she's surprised that they didn't get divorced.

FUSILLO: Because I had such overwhelming resentment.

ARNOLD: Money - nobody teaches us how to deal with this stuff in school, how to manage your finances with your spouse or partner. And part of the problem often seems to be that it's just very hard for couples to talk about money issues and resolve anything.

LAUREN PAPP: We know that these conflicts concerning money are difficult for couples to handle.

ARNOLD: Lauren Papp is a psychologist and a professor at the University of Wisconsin-Madison. She did a study where she followed 200 married people who kept diary entries about their arguments. And she found that we squabble more often about the kids or household chores, but she found that money can be one of the most damaging areas of conflict. That's because so much is wrapped up in it.

PAPP: Feelings about our self-worth or how much we're contributing, how much we've accomplished.

ARNOLD: OK, so what's a good approach to dealing with all of this?

KITTY BRESSINGTON: I get clients in all the time right for that question.

ARNOLD: Kitty Bressington is a financial adviser who specializes in helping couples. First up, she says...

BRESSINGTON: Get all of the issues out on the table, work through a budget, come to some agreement on yours, mine, ours, some spending limit types of things. Those all come from being able to talk about money, which as a society, we're not very good at.

ARNOLD: Bressington says, actually, she doesn't think it's a good idea to just throw all your money together into one account and hope for the best. But, she says, it is good for a couple to have a joint account to cover the basic bills. Then you need a plan for retirement savings, college, other long-term savings. But then there's the fun money that's discretionary.

BRESSINGTON: If you decided, say, $250 a month and that fits within your budget, and one person wants to blow his 250 and the other person wants to save her 250, that's OK 'cause you've set those ground rules.

ARNOLD: As far as Mary Fusillo, she and her husband eventually did figure out a better system. Now she's pretty much in charge of managing all of their finances.

FUSILLO: And that changed our relationship completely. We're a team now. I mean, he still makes more money than I do, but we're a team about it.

ARNOLD: And that is a very good place to be. We've got more tips online and in our Facebook group at npr.org/moneyandlife. Chris Arnold, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.